Pairings, Thoughtfully Crafted

Each pairing below is based on how flavors interact - sweetness, acidity, fat, heat, and umami - with the goal of complementing what’s in the glass rather than competing with it. These notes are meant as a guide. Taste is personal, and small changes in a drink can shift how a pairing lands.

Hot Honey Butter

Sweet • Warm • Rich
Buttery richness Honey sweetness Gentle chili heat Warm finish
Bourbon and whiskey pairing with Top Shelf Nuts Hot Honey Butter

Bourbon & Whiskey

Pairs best with: bourbon + balanced rye styles
Why it works

Honey and butter echo caramel and vanilla notes. The fat softens alcohol heat, while chili and black pepper extend the finish without overpowering the spirit.

Very smoky or aggressively spicy whiskies may dominate this pairing.
Malty beer pairing with Top Shelf Nuts Hot Honey Butter

Malty Beers

Try: amber ale, brown ale, Märzen
Why it works

Toasted malt sweetness mirrors honey and butter, while gentle heat adds contrast without clashing with bitterness. Easy, repeatable, and crowd-friendly.

Less suited for hop-forward or highly bitter beers.
Spiced or barrel-aged rum pairing with Top Shelf Nuts Hot Honey Butter

Spiced or Barrel-Aged Rum

Look for: vanilla, baking spice, oak
Why it works

Honey and butter highlight vanilla and baking-spice notes. Chili adds warmth that lingers gently, especially with barrel-aged or lightly spiced rums.

Heavily sweetened rums can make this pairing feel overly rich.

Want to start here? Hot Honey Butter is our go-to pairing for bourbon, malty beers, and warm-spice spirits.

Shop Hot Honey Butter

Umami Citrus Zing

Bright • Savory • Crisp
Lime + citrus zest Savory umami depth Subtle heat Clean finish
Gin and tonic pairing with Top Shelf Nuts Umami Citrus Zing

Gin & Tonic

Pairs best with: botanical or citrus-forward gins
Why it works

Citrus notes echo classic garnishes, while umami grounds tonic bitterness. Effervescence lifts the pairing and keeps the finish clean.

Very floral gins may shift the balance.
Crisp dry white wine pairing with Top Shelf Nuts Umami Citrus Zing

Crisp, Dry White Wine

Try: Sauvignon Blanc, Grüner Veltliner
Why it works

High acidity mirrors the citrus notes while savory elements add dimension without masking freshness. Bright and restrained.

Avoid heavily oaked or buttery whites.
Peaty whisky pairing with Top Shelf Nuts Umami Citrus Zing

Peaty Whisky (Islay & Coastal)

Best with: moderately peated styles
Why it works

Lime cuts through peatiness and lifts aroma, keeping smoke from feeling heavy. Umami mirrors the whisky’s depth, creating balance rather than blunt contrast.

Extremely medicinal or cask-strength expressions may still dominate.
Mezcal pairing with Top Shelf Nuts Umami Citrus Zing

Mezcal

Best with: moderately smoky Espadín styles
Why it works

Citrus lifts mezcal’s smoke and keeps it from feeling heavy, while savory umami aligns with its earthy, mineral character. The pairing stays focused and fresh rather than overpowering.

Very rustic, intensely smoky, or funky mezcals may dominate the citrus. A small sip of water or citrus garnish can help reset the balance.

Prefer brighter pairings? Umami Citrus Zing shines with gin, crisp whites, and peaty whisky.

Shop Umami Citrus Zing

How to Use This Guide

Practical tips

These pairings are meant to complement, not overpower. Proof, temperature, and garnish matter. If something feels heavy, try dilution, a lighter pour, or a touch of citrus to restore balance. Pairing should feel exploratory, not prescriptive.